TSAWDRONES

STATIC WING LOADING TEST

TechnologyOperations

by Devanshu Batra

18 June 2024

Static testing allows engineers to analyse an aircraft's structural integrity without leaving the ground. This is a valuable part of the testing process that helps speed up certification since it does not require a completed and fully functional aircraft.

So, what do manufacturers look to achieve with static testing? Ultimately, these procedures aim to replicate the forces that the aircraft will be subjected to once it does take to the skies. Engineers do so by applying forces to areas such as the aircraft's wings, fuselage, and tail.

However, planemakers aren't just testing flight conditions; they usually push the aircraft bar beyond its operating range. This ensures that, if the aircraft can withstand such abnormal pressure, it will have a size-able 'safety net' regarding its typical operations. The tests simulate the aircraft's responses to different forces in flight, providing engineers with information before it takes to the skies.

Fig 1- Static wing loading test being performed on an aircraft


There are various advantages of static testing .Static testing is helpful because it allows manufacturers to identify structural weaknesses before an aircraft takes to the skies. It’s like giving the plane a thorough health check before its maiden flight ,ensuring it can find faults before things go wrong. It also has a financial benefit for manufacturers, as writing off a test airframe will represent a smaller financial loss than scrapping a fully functional aircraft. Static tests are also less expensive to run than airborne trials, as Boeing found out in 2019.

These tests are also far less expensive to run than airborne ones and require fewer regulatory permissions since the risks of failure are lower. However, the inability to replicate exact flying conditions means these tests are restricted to checking structural integrity more than anything else, though an essential step on the road to certification.

Since the risks of failure are lower during static testing, regulatory permissions are easier to obtain compared to test flights.

Fig 2- Static test setup of an aircraft


To set up the system, we gathered all the necessary materials and equipment. First, we obtained an aircraft wing or a wing section as the primary subject of our experiment. To simulate the load, we acquired 20 packets of 1 kg salt, totaling 20 kg, or equivalent weights. These weights will be used as our load application mechanism. Additionally, we assembled various measuring instruments, including a measuring tape, vernier caliper, and support stand, to ensure precise measurements and accurate data collection. Finally, we constructed a robust support structure to securely hold the wing during the experiment. With all the components gathered, we proceeded to set up the system, ensuring everything was properly aligned and secured for a successful experiment.

Fig 3- Wing mounted on support structure
Fig 4- 20 kgs of load applied on the wing
Fig 5- A representation of static wing testing on an aircraft


Procedure:

Preparation: We set up the support structure for the wing and ensure it is securely in place. Placed the measuring tape and support stand at strategic points along the wing to measure deflection accurately.

Fig 6-  At no load condition , the initial reading is 64.8 cm from the ground


Initial Load: We started with a minimal load, such as 4 kgs, and apply it to the wing at both ends of the wing and measure the deflection.

Fig 6-  At 4 kgs of load on both sides of the wing  , the reading is 64.4 cm from the ground


Load Increment:

Now the load which was 4 kgs is increased to 7 kgs to check the deflection in the wing.

Fig 7-  At 7 kgs of load on both sides of the wing  , the reading is 62.8 cm from the ground


After crossing the 7 kgs mark , the deflection in the wing starts to change significantly , now the load is increased to 8 kgs on both sides of the wing.

At first the deflection in the left wing is checked.

Fig 8-  At 8 kgs of load on left side of the wing  , the reading  from the edge of wing is 61 cm from the ground
Fig 9-  At 8 kgs of load on left side of the wing  , the reading at 1 feet from the edge of wing is 63.5cm from the ground
Fig 10-  At 8 kgs of load on left side of the wing  , the reading at 2 feet from the edge of wing is 65cm from the ground
Fig 11-  At 8 kgs of load on left side of the wing  , the reading at 3 feet from the edge of wing is 65.5cm from the ground


After checking the deflection in the wing from the left side of the wing , now we check the wing deflection from the ride side of the wing with the same 8kgs of load

Fig 12-  At 8 kgs of load on right side of the wing  , the reading  from the edge of wing is 62.5 cm from the ground
Fig 13-  At 8 kgs of load on right side of the wing  , the reading at 1 feet from the edge of wing is 64.4cm from the ground
Fig 14-  At 8 kgs of load on right side of the wing  , the reading at 2 feet from the edge of wing is 65.7cm from the ground
Fig 15-  At 8 kgs of load on right side of the wing  , the reading at 3 feet from the edge of wing is 66.5cm from the ground


During the static wing loading test, the values recorded at 9 kg and 10 kg loads were found to be unreliable due to certain errors encountered during the measurements. As a result, these values were excluded from the final analysis and were not considered in the completion of the test. The data up to 8 kg load was used to assess the structural integrity of the wing, ensuring accurate and dependable results.

Data Analysis

During the static wing loading test, we applied incremental loads to the aircraft wing and measured the resulting deflections. Initial measurements were taken with no load, followed by loads of 4 kg, 7 kg, 8 kg, 9 kg, and 10 kg applied symmetrically and asymmetrically to the wing. Each load increment was carefully recorded to capture how the wing's structure responded to the increasing weight. The deflection measurements at various points along the wing provided insights into the structural integrity and flexibility of the wing under simulated conditions. By analyzing these data points, we were able to evaluate the performance of the wing and identify any potential weaknesses or areas of concern.

img
img
img


Conclusion

An aircraft wing's static forces during flight were accurately replicated by the static wing loading test, which yielded vital information about the structural integrity of the wing. By using accurate deflection measurements and applying incremental loads methodically, we were able to evaluate the wing's performance in a variety of scenarios. The findings showed that the wing could support loads of up to 10 kg on each side and that, as the load grew, the wing would deflect significantly.

The significance of static testing in detecting possible structural flaws prior to an aircraft taking to the air was highlighted by this experiment. It brought to light that wings can bend significantly under load, even with strong engineering, which is important to know in order to calculate safety margins. Manufacturers rely on these data to guarantee the dependability and safety of their aircraft.

Overall, the static wing loading test gave a thorough insight of the wing's structural behavior in addition to confirming the wing's capacity to support heavy loads. The certification procedure and subsequent advancements in aircraft design and safety procedures will benefit from this information.

Related Blogs